Good Witch / Bad Witch

Subject: Good Witch / Bad Witch Fri Mar 13, 2009 9:14 pm

What do you do when someone says:

"Oh, so you practice black magick because you practice Voodoo," or "You practice white magick because you are a Christian Witch"?

Paths are sometimes categorized as dark/black, light/white based on the name alone. Why do you think this is?

And what do you usually say to people that make these assumptions?

What would you recommend to educate the general populace that it is intent, rather than the practice itself that makes something light/dark, black/white?

Do you think it is in part the fault of the populace that represents these paths that they are perceived the way that they are? Or is it history, other religions, other figures that present them in this manner that have the greatest impact?

Teacher Number of posts : 35

Aside from the tricks of the movie or TV witch, usually accomplished with special camera techniques, there is no reason why any woman who puts her mind to it and learns the proper method cannot become a full-fledged witch in accord with popular conception. Only those who either do not know the means to success or are too stubborn to use them, once having been told, will persist in defining themselves as witches by using the sanctimonious definition of so-called 'White Witches' working for 'the benefit of mankind.' There will always be those who, furtively desiring personal power but unable to do anything about gaining it, devise their own definition of what a witch should be like, seeing to it, of course, that their definition fits themselves.

The 'White Witch' is the by-product of an emergence in England of an above-ground witchcraft interest at a time when witchcraft was still technically illegal. In order to pursue the 'craft' without harassment and prosecution, the spokesmen for witchcraft attempted to legitimize and justify what they were doing by proclaiming the existence of 'white' witchcraft. 'White' witchcraft, it was stated, was simply a belief in the religion of the old wise ones, or 'wicca'. The use of herbs, charms and healing spells was only employed for beneficial purposed.

It was to be believed that the kind of witches that were dangerous to have were 'black' witches. These were supposedly evil in their pursuits and worshiped Satan. The fact that the 'good' or 'white' witches employed a horned god in their ceremonies was justified because it 'doesn't represent the Devil!'.

Of course, no one admitted to practicing witchcraft ceremonies of any kind. Anything that was associated with witchcraft was pursued in the name of 'study' or 'research'. This was the climate in England between 1936 and 1951.

With the repeal of English witchcraft laws in 1951, all of the underground witches started creeping to the surface, and as their eyes became accustomed to the light of sudden legality, they ventured forth. Unused to such freedom and heavy with stigma of illegality, they went about shouting 'White Witchcraft' even louder than ever, as if expecting at any moment to be snared by a heretic hook.

About this time, interest in the occult was becoming popular in the U.S., so naturally attention was focussed on the British Isles with its rich heritage in all matters ghostly and fanciful. As might have been expected, newly emerged English Witches saw the U.S. as a fertile stamping ground for safe recognition of their 'witchiness'.

'White witch' became a definitive term and thousands who wouldn't touch the practice of witchcraft with a ten foot broomstick found conscience-redeeming opportunity to follow the 'art' by using the new rules of the game. Regardless of what these people would like to believe, the image of the witch has been stigmatized for centuries. All witches were considered to be agents of the Devil, antagonistic to scriptural teachings, and a direct part of the dark side of nature. As there is always a relative outlook as to what is good and what is evil, once witchcraft emerged from its 'all evil' state into neutral territory, a differentiation was bound to occur. The righteous, of course, will always wear the mantle of 'good', 'white light', 'spiritual' and varying shadows of holiness.

An analogy might be made concerning 'white' and 'black' witches. Let us assume that warfare had, for centuries, been called 'wholesome murder' and the men who fought called 'murderers'. One day it was decided that there was something quite noble and dignifies about this old activity of wholesome murder. All the murderers, basking in the light of new found legitimacy, began calling themselves 'good murderers.' The stigma of the word, 'murderer', still remains, but at least the good murderers felt little more at ease. Now, maybe these murderers always had a fairly legitimate reason for going into battle. Maybe they succeeded in saving their homeland from that which threatened it. They might have even had a scholar among them who had traced the origin of the word 'murderer' to an ancient word which meant 'mother'. But the fact remained, 'murderer' was still a negative term in the public's mind. So instead on simply revelling in their subsequent acceptance by the public, their guilt, brought about by long years of stigma, necessitated their placing of the word 'good' in front of 'murderer' as a sort of self-reassurance that they were doing the right thing!

Whenever a woman or girl becomes a 'White witch', you know she is either kidding herself or has much to learn.

Love and light

Lou xxx

Teacher Number of posts : 191

I simply tell people that statements such as "good" and "bad" are relative. I leave it at that.

» I Am A Witch
» What kind of Witch are you?
» The 13 Principles of a Witch
» You known your neighbor is a witch when....
» The Witch's Chant